Agree if you were taking a girl out for an impressive romantic dinner then a buffet would not be the way to go.
A nice a la carte restaurant would be more romantic.
But the OP says his girlfriend loves a good seafood buffet, so she sounds like a down to earth girl, so The Star would be great for that.
Also the pandemic has actually made buffets much nicer because they are much more civilised now, with staff serving you, so you are not wrestling with angry aunties going straight for the most expensive items