
Originally Posted by
FIFO
Damn I've been following this thread because I'm back in Syd soon and really interested in Midori.
I really don't want to take sides here but damn a few things here seems a bit questionable.
You guys are arguing about subjective scores here, everyone has their own way of scoring no matter what people think or try to do this cannot be objective. Although I agree that Tcrawford has a harsh rating scale, however, once he explained it, it made sense to me. He said that a 5/10 is by definition average, and so his scores start from there. He mentioned that a 7/10 is pretty (since this is +2 from average) and it is impossible to be a 10 since this would imply perfection (I agree with this actually).
Not to point anyone out, but I think the bros in this forum (me included) try to be nice to the girls and we start our scale much higher (for average) than 5/10. I'm pretty sure i've seen some reviewers who have literally never rated a girl under a 7/10. This is probably not ideal, but I have never NOT given a 10 to ginza reception when they ask for a rating for the girl. I say 10 everytime, because i don't want to affect the girl in anyway, and honestly, i just don't care. If i didn't like her, then i will just not see her again, other people might like her, i don't care because I personally didn't like her. Different strokes for different blokes. There are blokes here when they score, i will just minus 2 every time, so why not for tcrawford, just +2 to his score everytime. There are blokes whose taste is just too far from mine that i don't bother with their reviews. The examples are endless, but damn people get offended by the weirdest things imo.
Again, scores are subjective, are people comparing to all women (WL and non-WL) or just WL only? I think the average WL is in general much prettier than the average non-WL (because, then they wouldn't have a job), but is this how people rate? I don't know. A score comparing WLs with all women in general is going to be very different to a score that compares WLs to only WLs. There's just so many factors here before we even talk about personal preference/taste.
I'm not going to comment on the shill stuff because damn it seems like that is a dangerous line to walk.
However, i want to comment on the 'Rule no. 8". I understand why this rule exist however i want to pose the question then, if someone writes a NEGATIVE AR about a shop/girl does that mean no one can counter/criticise the OP with the contrary? Since it's offending? Because that's what that rule would suggest. This all just seems so egregious as i have never seen this enforced in the negative case.
But back on topic, god damn Midori looks good, i hope she's still in Sydney next week when i come!