I don't like water based neither. Eg, KY
That's why i use Wet Stuff which is silicon based, though, I've never used oil based such as baselin! I think it will be very sticky.. And hard to wash out.
Yesterday i bought new type of lube, which is 3 times expensive than Wet stuff, 6times than KY.
The adult shop clerk said that I should choose goooood one because it will be in my body, so I was strongly dazzled LOL
This is the new type of lube which made in germany. I will try on this weekend..
This is also silicon-based.