Isnt it always ymmv? So for him that amazing girl may not have been such an amazing girl for others. Who knows? This is all opinion... this whole forum is about personal opinions. Why are u guys all being bitches to a dude who's giving us his feedback on someone he saw? He also quite literally put in his post that he can't remember who it was and will update when he remembers.
Maybe he hasn't had a punt for a while and that one girl made it amazing for him.

Fuck, us guys can be more of a bitch then girls.