My list these days is pretty narrow, found good consistent places and tend to stick with them.
227 Broadway - consistently good service. I know what I'm getting. Shower in the room, minimum level of service and on average good massages. Extras are becoming more common here than they used to be.
MAC - if you know you know, never disappointed with my visit here, though i wouldn't go here if I was after a quality massage.
200 Stanmore - Ada is sexy and chooses sexy girls to work at her shop. Consistently good service for both part 1 and 2.