I would say Alice is definitely the best at Smith St but have had plenty of other good P2 there, including a CBJ from someone whose name escapes me. Alice is good because her P1 is awesome, so I would go see her even if it was just for that. And the staff rotate at the Cardiff shop as well, which I have yet to visit. Bit less accessible and more public facing.
Speaking of public facing, anyone have more intel on 106 High St East Maitland? There was a post here a few months ago but that user has only had that post, so I am wondering if it was just a shill advertising the place.